Last Updated on June 28, 2025 by Matt Musico
The baseball card market continues to captivate collectors and investors, as certain baseball cards command astronomical prices that would make anyone do a double-take. While we’ve witnessed jaw-dropping sales like the $12.6 million Mickey Mantle rookie card, the question on every collector’s mind remains: which cards could be next in line to set some records?
Recent analysis from industry experts at Gold Card Auctions and Pristine Auction (h/t GOBankingRates.com’s Nicholas Morine) has identified four baseball cards that could potentially accomplish this over the next five years. These pieces represent potential goldmines for those savvy enough to recognize their trajectory as early as possible.
Editor’s Note: New to MLB Daily Dingers? Then Start Here!
4 Baseball Cards to Keep an Eye on
The expert consensus has zeroed in on the following four cards:
- Ken Griffey Jr.’s 1989 Upper Deck Rookie Card (#1) – The iconic card featuring Junior’s trademark smile has experienced explosive growth recently, with PSA 10 examples steadily climbing in value.
- Paul Skenes’ 2023 Bowman Draft 1st Bowman Chrome Card – Skenes cards are in high demand after his dominant rookie year and a sophomore campaign that’s been just as impressive. This card represents the cutting edge of modern collecting, combining stellar performance with pristine card design.
- Barry Bonds’ 1986 Topps Traded Tiffany #11T – Currently considered undervalued by market standards, this card carries the potential for massive appreciation if Bonds ever gets into the Hall of Fame despite his controversial legacy (FWIW, I think he should be in).
- Gunnar Henderson’s 2023 Topps Series 1 Rookie Card – The Baltimore Orioles sensation’s card reflects his American League Rookie of the Year performance and Silver Slugger award. While the O’s are having a disappointing 2025, Henderson is still an intriguing young talent in just his age-24 season. This card was also picked out during the 2024-25 offseason when the shortstop was fresh off a 37-homer performance and finishing fourth in AL MVP Award voting.
Out of the four cards listed here, I feel as though the Henderson card has the greatest chance to not appreciate like the others.
The Griffey Jr. Phenomenon: Why #1 Still Matters
Ken Griffey Jr.’s Upper Deck rookie card holds a special place in collecting lore, and for good reason. This isn’t just another rookie card. It’s the card that launched Upper Deck as a premium brand. The fact that it bears the coveted #1 designation makes it even more symbolic.
What makes this card particularly intriguing is its recent price acceleration. While many cards from the late 1980s have struggled to maintain relevance in today’s market, Junior’s rookie continues defying gravity. The combination of his near-unanimous Hall of Fame selection, his status as arguably the most naturally gifted player of his generation, and the card’s pristine photography creates a perfect storm for continued appreciation.
Industry insiders point to the card’s crossover appeal because it attracts both serious collectors and casual fans who remember watching Griffey’s sweet swing in the 1990s. That broad appeal translates into sustained demand, and sustained demand drives prices higher.
The New Generation: Skenes Leads The Way
Modern rookie cards face a different landscape than their vintage counterparts, but Skenes represents the best of what contemporary collecting offers. His dominant rookie campaign and an equally dominant start to 2025 with Pittsburgh showcases the kind of electric stuff that translates into long-term collecting value. His 2023 Bowman Draft card benefits from Bowman’s reputation as the premier rookie card brand, while his on-field performance provides the substance to back up the hype.
Skenes embodies the modern collector’s dream: a young superstar with a lengthy career ahead of him, and a card that captures the right-hander at the absolute beginning of his professional journey.
The Evolution of Card Collecting: Past, Present, and Future
The baseball card landscape has undergone seismic shifts over the past five years, fundamentally altering how we approach collecting and investing. The explosion of grading services, the influence of social media, and the integration of technology have created a more sophisticated but also more accessible market than ever before.
Where collectors once relied on price guides and local card shops for market information, today’s enthusiasts have real-time sales data, population reports, and global marketplaces at their fingertips. This transparency has simultaneously increased competition and educated buyers, creating more efficient pricing but also higher barriers to entry for premium cards.
Looking ahead, the next five years promise even more dramatic changes. Blockchain authentication, fractional ownership, and digital integration are already beginning to reshape the hobby. The cards identified in the GOBankingRates analysis represent not just collecting opportunities, but test cases for how traditional cardboard performs in an increasingly digital world.
The smart money suggests that cards combining historical significance, player excellence, and scarcity will continue commanding premium prices regardless of technological advances. Whether these four specific cards ultimately break records remains to be seen, but that’s part of the fun, isn’t it?
Love home runs? Sign up for my Substack today and start getting interesting home run-related observations straight to your inbox!
Leave a Reply