Last Updated on June 25, 2025 by Matt Musico
Atlanta Braves starting pitcher Chris Sale recently achieved a huge career milestone by recording his 2,500th strikeout. He joins just three other active pitchers in this club: Justin Verlander, Max Scherzer, and Clayton Kershaw. Could this accomplishment help Chris Sale baseball card values in the near future?
SI.com’s Rich Brummett pointed out three specific Chris Sale baseball cards that could rise in value. Thanks to the southpaw’s resurgence in Atlanta — which includes winning his first Cy Young Award — he’s building an intriguing Hall of Fame case. The current market also presents what might be a closing window for acquiring some of his top cards at a great value.
Editor’s Note: New to MLB Daily Dingers? Then Start Here!
Which Chris Sale Baseball Card Values Could Rise?
According to Brummett, several Sale cards stand out as particularly compelling targets for collectors looking to capitalize:
• 2010 Bowman Chrome Draft #BDPP88 (RC) – This card holds the distinction of being Sale’s true rookie card in the eyes of most collectors. PSA 10 examples can still be found for under $100, a fraction of what comparable rookie cards from his peer group command.
• 2011 Topps Chrome RC – A flagship favorite that appeals to set builders and individual collectors alike. The Chrome treatment gives this card the premium feel that modern collectors crave, yet it remains surprisingly accessible in terms of pricing.
• 2010 Donruss Elite Extra Edition Autograph – For autograph collectors, this early career signature card offers a unique design aesthetic and serial numbering that adds to its appeal. It represents Sale during his pre-MLB days, making it a fascinating piece of his collecting timeline.
Why Sale’s Cards Could Experience Significant Growth
The market dynamics surrounding Sale’s cards present an interesting case for potential appreciation. While advanced statistics have revolutionized how we analyze baseball, strikeouts remain one of the sport’s most universally appreciated and exciting accomplishments. Reaching 2,500 career strikeouts isn’t merely about longevity. It demonstrates sustained excellence and dominance over more than a decade.
Sale’s unique delivery and devastating slider made him appointment television during his prime years from 2012 to 2018. Now, his resurgence with the Braves has reminded everyone why he was once considered among the game’s elite arms. This combination of past dominance and current relevance creates the perfect storm for card value appreciation.
The comparison to his contemporaries becomes even more striking when you examine their respective card markets. Verlander rookies in PSA 10 condition command premium prices, while Kershaw rookie autographs regularly reach four-figure territory. Scherzer’s parallels and low-numbered cards have developed strong collector followings. Sale’s cards haven’t yet experienced this same level of market appreciation.
The 2010 Bowman Chrome Draft: The Crown Jewel of Sale’s Portfolio
This card represents everything collectors should want in a long-term hold. First, it carries the official rookie card designation that serious collectors demand. Second, the Bowman Chrome brand has established itself as the gold standard for modern rookie cards, particularly for pitchers. The refractor technology and overall card quality make it a premium product that ages well in collections.
Most important, though, is the pricing. Finding PSA 10 examples under $100 means collectors aren’t paying a premium for speculation – they’re acquiring a legitimate piece of baseball history at what could prove to be ground-floor prices. If Sale eventually reaches 3,000 strikeouts or receives serious Hall of Fame consideration, this card will likely be the centerpiece that collectors chase.
Sale’s Hall of Fame Trajectory and Legacy Impact
Chris Sale’s career resume reads like a Hall of Fame case study in progress. His eight All-Star appearances demonstrate sustained excellence, while his three strikeout titles (2015, 2017, 2024) show he’s remained elite across different phases of his career. The recent NL Cy Young Award and Pitching Triple Crown in 2024 prove that his best days weren’t necessarily behind him once the Boston Red Sox traded him to Atlanta.
The 2,500-strikeout milestone places Sale in rarefied air. If he continues his current trajectory and reaches 3,000 strikeouts, his Cooperstown case gets even better. Even without reaching that benchmark, his peak dominance and career totals make for compelling arguments.
For collectors, this represents the sweet spot where current achievement meets future potential. Sale isn’t a speculative prospect or a declining veteran hanging on for nostalgia. He’s an active player still contributing at an elite level while building an increasingly impressive legacy.
The beauty of Sale’s current market position lies in the disconnect between his on-field accomplishments and his cardboard valuation. While headlines focus on young stars and flashy prospects, seasoned collectors understand that veterans with Hall of Fame credentials often provide the most reliable long-term value appreciation. Sale’s 2,500-strikeout achievement serves as a perfect reminder that elite pitching performance, when properly recognized by the collecting community, can create substantial returns for those who recognized the opportunity early.
Love home runs? Sign up for my Substack today and start getting interesting home run-related observations straight to your inbox!
Leave a Reply