The 1967 Topps baseball cards set is a beloved hobby release from the vintage era. With its clean design and loaded roster of Hall of Famers, high-grade examples have been in demand for decades.
Let’s look a little closer at five cards from this set and see how much they could be worth in today’s market.
Editor’s Note: Looking to Sell Sports Cards? Here’s How to Do It Quickly & Easily
Five 1967 Topps Baseball Cards Worth Serious Money
Here are the headliners from this classic set that caught my eye, as well as valuation information from Sports Cards Pro data:
Whitey Ford #5: The Yankees legend’s card soared into five-figure territory recently. A PSA 10 example sold at Heritage Auctions in November 2025 for $26,840.
Al Kaline #30: The value of Mr. Tiger’s card has shown a dramatic increase based on the last two recorded PSA 10 sales noted by Sports Cards Pro data. An eBay sale in 2021 went for $8,800, but a November 2025 sale at Heritage hammered for $14,640.
Willie Stargell #140: Pops’ card has fetched around $1,100 in its two most recent PSA 9 sales, making it one of the set’s most attainable Hall of Fame investments.
AL HR Leaders #243: Featuring Frank Robinson, Harmon Killebrew, and Boog Powell, this multi-player card has been selling for $50-$100 in PSA 8 condition on eBay recently.
NL HR Leaders #244: The Hank Aaron, Dick Allen, and Willie Mays combo features a trio of Hall of Famers, with a PSA 9 example most recently sold for $600 on eBay in March 2025.
Killebrew and Robinson: The AL’s Power Summit
The 1966 season was Frank Robinson’s first in Baltimore after the Cincinnati Reds traded him. He not only led the American League with 49 homers, but he also took home the Triple Crown (.316 average and 122 RBI), won the AL MVP Award, and won the World Series. Not a bad first impression!
That same year, Harmon Killebrew finished second in the league with 39 bombs for Minnesota, continuing his decade-long reign as one of the AL’s most feared power hitters. This was one of 10 times he surpassed the 30-homer plateau between 1959 and 1970.
This card is actually pretty affordable in lower grades, with PSA 7 examples recently trading hands for $20-$75, according to Sports Cards Pro. But that jump to PSA 10 territory is where things get expensive, but it’s still not prohibitive for many collectors at around the $600 mark.
Aaron and Mays: The NL’s Greatest Power Duo
If the AL card is impressive, the NL HR Leaders card is legendary. Hank Aaron hit 44 home runs in 1966, while Willie Mays finished third behind Dick Allen with 37 despite playing half his games in pitcher-friendly Candlestick Park.
This card trades at a premium over its AL counterpart, and rightfully so. You’re getting three Hall of Famers on one card, which includes two of the five greatest players in baseball history on a single piece of cardboard. In PSA 8 condition, expect to pay around $100-$300. A PSA 9 example sold for $600 last March, while PSA 10 examples are valued at nearly $1,800.
Both legends were still performing at elite levels in 1966. Aaron was 32 and chasing Babe Ruth’s all-time home run record, while the 35-year-old Mays remained one of the game’s most complete players.
The 1967 Topps Set’s Lasting Appeal
The 1967 Topps release moved away from the more complex layouts of the early 1960s toward cleaner presentations. The set contains 609 cards, making it one of the larger releases of the decade. Centering issues plague the entire product, which is exactly why perfectly centered PSA 10 examples can fetch such high prices.
Beyond the stars, this set features plenty of rookie cards worth pursuing, including Rod Carew and Tom Seaver. The high-number series (#534-609) is tough to find for set builders since these cards were printed in smaller quantities.
What really sets this release apart is the depth of the star power. You’re not just getting a handful of Hall of Famers—you’ve got Mickey Mantle, Roberto Clemente, Sandy Koufax’s final card, and dozens more legends all in one set. For vintage collectors, it’s one of the best blends of affordability in lower grades and investment potential in gem mint condition.
Love home runs? Sign up for my Substack today and start getting interesting home run-related observations straight to your inbox! And if you’re new to MLB Daily Dingers, it’s probably best to start here.
