Last Updated on March 12, 2026 by Matt Musico
Any piece of cardboard featuring Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani is special these days. But when you put them together on a 1-of-1 issue and add their signatures to it? That’s when things really get interesting (and lucrative for whoever owns it).
The Athletic’s Larry Holder first reported on the listing of the unique card we’re about to discuss, which is available for bidding via Fanatics Collect through March 19.
Editor’s Note: Looking to Sell Sports Cards? Here’s How to Do It Quickly & Easily
What Makes This Aaron Judge-Shohei Ohtani Card So Special
Here’s a look at the card creating all this buzz. It’s the 2025 Topps MVP Gold Logoman, which is a 1-of-1 dual auto featuring Judge and Ohtani.
Topps rolled out a new program heading into 2025 tied to the previous year’s award winners. Players who won MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year honors in 2024 wore gold versions of the silhouetted MLB logo patch on the back of their jerseys throughout the season.
While every other player in the league has patches that match their team’s color scheme, these versions immediately stuck out. A limited number of patches were cut from the jerseys at the end of the year and inserted into trading card packs through redemption cards.
The Auction Records That This Card Could Challenge
The benchmark everyone keeps coming back to is the 2007-08 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection dual Logoman autographed patch card featuring Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant that Holder mentioned. That bad boy sold for $12.9 million in 2025. It included logo patches cut directly from each player’s game-worn NBA jerseys. Could this be a potential comp for the Jude-Ohtani card?
Nobody is projecting that kind of sale price, but Card Ladder co-founder Chris McGill flagged some cards worth thinking about. They range from a one-of-one Kobe Bryant/LeBron James 2009-10 Upper Deck Exquisite auto, which brought $1.2 million at auction, all the way up to the Jordan/Bryant record.
For even more context, a non-autographed dual Ohtani/Judge Gold Logoman card (with just four copies available) went for nearly $165,000 through Heritage in late January. The autographed, truly one-of-one version? That’s a completely different stratosphere, folks.
At the time of this writing, this card has already reached the $1 million mark after 36 bids, and there’s still plenty of time for action to heat up.
The Most Expensive Ohtani and Judge Cards Ever Sold Right Now
Ohtani’s all-time high actually lives in this same Gold Logoman world. His 2025 Topps Chrome one-of-one MVP Award Gold Logoman autographed card sold for $3 million on December 19, 2025. That’s the individual ceiling this dual card would need to clear on the Ohtani side. Given the added rarity of a dual auto and the fact that we’re already at $1 million, that seems likely to happen.
Judge’s personal high sale was a bit more modest by comparison. His 2013 Bowman Chrome Superfractor one-of-one auto, graded BGS 9.5 on the card with a 10 on the signature, sold for $324,000 back in May 2022. Things have changed quite a bit since then — both in the hobby and on the field, thanks to historic performances from the right-handed slugger. Fanatics Collect just announced that this card sold for $5.2 million via private sale, which has set a new record for modern baseball cards.
Card Ladder’s current estimate on that same card sits around $1.43 million.
Could Judge and Ohtani Both Win Three Straight MVPs?
This situation is even more interesting and compelling as a long-term investment piece because of what both players have recently accomplished.
Judge took home American League MVP honors in both 2024 and 2025, while Ohtani claimed the National League MVP in back-to-back fashion over that same stretch. If either (or both) repeats in 2026, the historical weight this card already carries only goes up.
There have been only 13 MLB players to win three or more MVP Awards during their career, but if we drill that down to three consecutive MVPs? That’s genuinely rare territory. Only Barry Bonds (he won four straight from 2001-04) and Ohtani (2023 for the Angels, 2024-25 for the Dodgers) have done it. Although Ohtani already has a three-peat under his belt, he’s going for three straight NL MVPs and a chance to join Bonds as only the second player to win the honor four years in a row.
Judge and Ohtani are already the first pair of players to win MVPs in consecutive seasons at the same time, which is part of what makes this card remarkable. Another MVP for one or both players in 2026? That sends it into a completely different conversation about legacy — and value.
Love home runs? Sign up for my Substack today and start getting interesting home run-related observations straight to your inbox! And if you’re new to MLB Daily Dingers, it’s probably best to start here.
