Goodwill Goldmine: Rare Baseball Memorabilia Haul Bought for Under $20

Christopher Kidney lived through what pretty much every baseball memorabilia collector dreams about.

He walked into his local Goodwill in Kentucky and left with a haul that had the entire sports memorabilia community buzzing. Kidney discovered a collection of rare baseball memorabilia and signed cards for less than $20, according to Newsweek’s Alice Gibbs.

The crown jewel of his haul? A Yogi Berra-signed baseball. But that’s just the beginning of this unreal thrift store trip that proves sometimes the best finds are hiding in plain sight.

Editor’s Note: New to MLB Daily Dingers? Then Start Here!

The Yogi Berra Autographed Baseball Discovery

Berra’s signature commands serious respect in today’s market. The legendary catcher, who was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1972, remains one of the most beloved figures in Yankees history. His authentic autographs are increasingly rare following his passing in 2015.

What makes this discovery particularly fascinating is Kidney’s ability to immediately recognize the authenticity markers that separate genuine signed pieces from the countless reproductions flooding the market. “When I saw the names on the cards, I could tell they were real based on the brand,” Kidney explained to Newsweek, showing the kind of expertise that separates casual browsers from serious collectors.

Berra’s signature characteristics (including his distinctive “Y” and consistent pen pressure) are hard to forge, making authentic pieces like this even more valuable. The fact that someone donated such a treasure to Goodwill speaks to the hidden gems that circulate through thrift stores daily.

A Pattern of Incredible Rare Baseball Memorabilia Finds

Kidney’s Goodwill success story extends beyond this occurrence. Kidney also found a 1949 book signed by Honus Wagner. This discovery cost him just $1.59, representing the kind of return on investment that makes collecting addictive for those who know what to look for.

The emotional significance of these finds runs deeper than monetary value for Kidney, too. He credits his late grandfather, who worked for multiple pro teams (Reds, Giants, and Cardinals) as inspiration for his collecting passion. “I truly believe in some divine way I was meant to find this book,” Kidney said, highlighting how family connections often drive the most passionate collectors.

The Supporting Cast: CC Sabathia, Don Mattingly, and More

Kidney also discovered autographed cards from CC Sabathia and Don Mattingly — two players whose signatures represent different eras of baseball excellence. The collection included a signed Super Bowl XLII card from New York Giants wide receiver Plaxico Burress, too. This diversity suggests an estate donation or family clearing situation.

His discovery gained massive traction on Reddit, where his post detailing the find led to over 1,500 upvotes and dozens of congratulatory comments from fellow collectors. “Incredible, still shaking,” he captioned his photos, perfectly capturing the adrenaline rush every treasure hunter knows very well.

The social media attention reflects how modern collecting has evolved beyond quiet transactions into community celebrations of remarkable finds. Fellow Redditors offered both congratulations and a nudge to get what he found authenticated as soon as possible.

This online validation process has become important to the collecting experience, where sharing finds builds credibility and connects enthusiasts from all over. 

Why Thrift Store Hunting Remains Golden

Kidney’s success story represents more than lucky timing. It shows the opportunities available to knowledgeable collectors willing to invest time in searching. His previous discovery of that 1949 Honus Wagner-signed book for just $1.59 proves this wasn’t beginner’s luck but rather the result of his expertise and consistent effort.

The entire collection sold privately for over $500, representing a 2,500% return on his initial investment of under $20. These margins might seem huge, but they reflect the genuine scarcity of authenticated vintage sports memorabilia in today’s marketplace.

Most importantly, Kidney’s story reminds us that incredible discoveries still await those willing to look beyond obvious sources. While online auctions and specialty dealers dominate the market, thrift stores continue offering the possibility of life-changing finds for those who know what to seek and how to recognize authenticity when they see it.

Love home runs? Sign up for my Substack today and start getting interesting home run-related observations straight to your inbox!