If you’re a serious vintage card collector, you’ll be excited by what’s currently being auctioned off at Heritage. I mean, it’s only one of the most iconic baseball card sets ever produced!
A complete 1933 Goudey Baseball set (all 239 cards) is available for bidding. This is a release that fundamentally changed how baseball cards were sold to the public, and those who have deep pockets can toss their hat into the ring to get the entire set.
Editor’s Note: Looking to Sell Sports Cards? Here’s How to Do It Quickly & Easily
The Heritage Auctions Listing: What’s Actually Up for Grabs
According to the Heritage Auctions listing, this 1933 Goudey Baseball set includes all 239 cards from the original release, with 16 professionally graded by SGC. The graded portion features some legitimate heavy hitters: three SGC 50 VG/EX 4 cards including Eddie Collins (#42), Waite Hoyt (#60), and Joe Cronin (#189), plus three SGC 45 VG+ 3.5 cards with Jimmie Foxx (#29), Moe Berg (#158), and Mel Ott (#207).
The real excitement is for two of the dudes in pinstripes. There are four Babe Ruth cards graded by SGC (#53, #144, #149, and #181) with grades ranging from SGC 30 to SGC 35, along with two Lou Gehrig cards (#92 and #160), both graded SGC 30. These obviously aren’t in pristine shape, but let’s not forget that they’re authentic pieces of cardboard from nearly 100 years ago.
As of this writing, the top bid for this lot stands at exactly $28,000 ($34,160 when factoring in the buyer’s premium).
Why the 1933 Goudey Baseball Set Changed Everything
The 1933 Goudey Baseball set is special because it was the first major baseball card release to include bubble gum in every pack. Before Goudey came along, cards were distributed with tobacco and candy products. The Goudey Gum Company took another risk by launching this set in the thick of the Great Depression. After all, banks were failing and nearly a quarter of Americans were unemployed, but Goudey went ahead anyway by producing a 239-card set featuring colorized player photos on thicker cardstock.
Obviously, this gamble paid off for the company. Collectors who grew up with Topps and Bowman can trace the concept of gum-packed baseball cards directly back to Goudey.
Each card featured dramatic player poses against bold red, yellow, green, and blue backgrounds, with most including the “Big League Chewing Gum” banner. PSA has graded over 82,000 individual 1933 Goudey cards so far. However, only about 13% of them grade at PSA 7 or better. As you can imagine, that scarcity drives serious market demand.
The Headliners: Ruth, Gehrig, and the Legendary #106 Lajoie
Goudey included four different Ruth cards in the set, including #53 (the “Yellow Ruth”), #144 (full-body batting pose), #149 (the “Red Ruth”), and #181 (the “Green Ruth”). Card #53 with its yellow background is the most valuable, but #144 was double-printed to compensate for the infamous missing #106 Nap Lajoie card. Despite being more common, #144 still commands massive prices, evidenced by a near-mint example selling for $4.2 million in 2022.
Gehrig appears on two nearly identical cards: #92 and #160. Both of them show The Iron Horse getting ready to hit. Card #160 is a lot harder to find, with a PSA population around 850 compared to roughly 1,500 for #92.
The Lajoie #106 tells the set’s most interesting story. Goudey deliberately omitted this card from original production, which created artificial scarcity that drove collectors crazy. The customer complaints poured in, so Goudey finally produced #106 in 1934 and mailed copies to collectors who requested it, but many were damaged by a paper clip. PSA and SGC combined have graded fewer than 140 examples, making it one of the most elusive cards in the vintage world.
What Makes This Set a Smart Long-Term Investment
The 1933 Goudey set combines everything collectors love to hunt for: legit historical significance as the first gum-paired baseball card set, terrific visuals, huge star power with Ruth and Gehrig (among others), and more than 60 Hall of Famers throughout the set.
Most surviving cards show their age. After all, 90-year-old cardboard that spent decades in shoeboxes and dresser drawers is bound to show some wear and tear. But for collectors working with realistic budgets, putting lower-grade versions of the key cards makes a lot of sense. You don’t need a PSA 8 Ruth to own a piece of this legacy. Even Good or VG examples of the four Ruth cards, both Gehrigs, or standouts like Ott, give you authentic vintage cardboard from this era.
The Heritage auction is a good example here. With graded cards ranging from SGC 30 to SGC 50, it’s a complete representation of one of the hobby’s most important releases. Whether you’re bidding on complete sets or gradually building your own collection one by one, you’re investing in the foundation of baseball card collecting.
Love home runs? Sign up for my Substack today and start getting interesting home run-related observations straight to your inbox! And if you’re new to MLB Daily Dingers, it’s probably best to start here.
